Free World U top bar image
Free World U Blog Graphic

Book or Movie? What Should We Do First?

by Miriam Downey 30. July 2014 07:40

 

 What do you like to do first--read the book or see the movie? My grandchildren and I had an interesting discussion about this dilemma around the breakfast table the other day. I was asking specifically about the movie The Fault in Our Stars, which my 13-year-old granddaughters had just seen. I have this book by John Green sitting on my desk, waiting for an afternoon so I can read it before I watch the movie. I asked the girls if they would like to read the book now that they had seen the movie. Thus the conversation. The girls had loved the movie so much that they both wanted to read the book.

My 17-year-old grandson piped up and said that he liked to read books after he had seen the movie. He said that when he read the Hunger Games books, he had the vision of the characters from the movie in his mind. He was quick to add that he had loved the Percy Jackson books so much that the movie didn't compare to the images he had in his mind. So, as we discussed the issue, what emerged was the idea that it can go both ways--sometimes the book is better; sometimes the movie.

So, here's a summer challenge for you. There are a wealth of movies based on children and teen books. Today I am going to give you a list of ten book-movie pairings for elementary grade children. Next week I will give you a list of book-movie pairings for middle and high school-aged kids. Try them out both ways--movie first and then book first. See which one you like best.

I have provided a link for the book if it is available online. Of course, the books will all be available at the library, and it is likely that the movies will be available at the library as well, but they will also be available at some of your other movie sources. I also indicated the year of the movie. This is only a partial list. A more complete list of book-movie pairings can be found here.

 

Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll. (The movie is the Walt Disney version updated in 2010).

Charlotte's Web by E.B. White. (Animated version 1973 and live version 2006).

Five Children and It by E. Nesbit. (Movie is 2005).

James and the Giant Peach by Roald Dahl. (Disney Version, 2010).

Jumanji by Chris Van Allsburg. (movie 2000).

Ballet Shoes by Noel Streatfield. (movie 2008).

Holes by Louis Sacher. (movie 2003).

The Jungle Book by Rudyard Kipling. (Disney version updated 2007).

Mary Poppins by P.L. Travers (movie updated version 2009). Also a new movie about the making of the Mary Poppins movie called Saving Mr. Banks (2013).

Mr. Popper's Penguins by Richard and Florence Atwater. (movie 2011).

Where the Red Fern Grows by Wilson Rawls. (movie 1997).

Tags:

Blog | English

Comments (1) -

Karina Kapoor
Karina Kapoor United States
7/31/2014 6:24:41 PM #

Nice post

Reply

Add comment

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading

About the author

RecentPosts

Page List

Month List

Free World U bottom bar image